For small- and mid-sized businesses (SMBs), HR shouldn’t be the equivalent of having to wrestle with a spreadsheet lumbering out of control; however, as your team and organization grow, the flaws in manual processes become evident: payroll errors, missing onboarding procedures, and disgruntled employees arise. This is where modern HR software can be a lifesaver.
But, there are many options out there in the market. How do you determine which option meets the requirement? Based on our near-zero-cost evaluation for 2025, the trio that stands out includes BambooHR, Gusto, and Rippling. All three provide cloud-based HR tools that help businesses simplify people operations, but provide software with unique capabilities.
BambooHR is known for people operations and onboarding.
Gusto is built for payroll and compliance.
Rippling has considerable automation capabilities, built for back-office scaling through HR, IT, and finance.
This guide is for busy professionals, every founder’s best friend, and HR leaders looking for factual and practical information. We will compare features and pricing, contextualize use cases, and document user experience to define the right option as a fit, not just for now, but for the future, too.
Because when HR is east, your business runs smart.
The reality is that many SMBs don't have HR departments on day one; it will normally be a founder, office manager, or finance person doing HR along with a million (give or take) other things. That is why SMBs are looking for HR that is a bit more "teammate-ish" and less just an HR tool.
The ideal HR application for a small business should have an easy user experience, be quick to implement, and be affordable. The HR application should cover off the essentials - employee records, onboarding, time off, payroll, etc. - without introducing even more layers of complexity. At the same time, the HR application should be adjustable to allow for the growth of the business.
Micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) account for 66% of employment in advanced economies and 54% of value added, underscoring how critical they are for growth.
Flexibility is another aspect. If you have an entirely remote team, a hybrid workforce, or hourly employees, you'll want HR software that's compliant, capable of automation, and utilizes integrations to save you a whole bunch of time.
What else is important? Big things like transparent pricing, responsive customer support, mobile compatibility, and integrations to make it easy to sync with quoting, Slack, and/or Google Workspace.
When it comes down to it, small businesses want HR tools that allow people, not processes, to succeed. In the end, you just want fewer logins, fewer headaches, and more time to focus on the people who do the work, as well as customers and growth.
So now, the real question is, what tool does all that?
Choosing the right HR tool starts with knowing the core purpose behind each platform. Although BambooHR, Gusto, and Rippling all classify as “HR software,” they each have their priorities for small and midsize businesses (SMBs).
BambooHR - Built for People Management
BambooHR is built for the employee experience. Everything from applicant tracking and onboarding to PTO tracking and performance can easily be done through its clean and easy-to-use interface. It is particularly useful for SMBs that want a lightweight HRIS to house employee records and workflows.
Payroll is an add-on, but the focus is HR.
Gusto - Payroll First, HR Second
Gusto (formerly known as Gusto Payroll) started as a payroll solution, and is still focused on payroll automation and benefit administration. Gusto can automate not only tax filings and compliance support, but also has direct deposit and contractor payments. Gusto does provide the basic HR tools necessary to onboard an employee (e.g., onboarding checklist) along with time tracking and self-service, but payroll is what Gusto is best a,t with ease of use for U.S.-based payroll.
Gusto is a popular option for founders who want to "set it and forget it" when it comes to payroll.
Rippling - Your Automation Hub
Rippling is the most technically sophisticated of the three. It unifies people, operations, tech infrastructure, and financial workflows within a single digital environment. This means you can automate workflows, onboard employees, assign devices, provision apps (Slack, Zoom), and payroll all in one place.
Rippling has 500+ integrations and global payroll abilities, definitely a consideration for tech-enabled SMBs looking for automation and scale.
All platforms have aligned on what they support as part of their business philosophies:
BambooHR = HR first.
Gusto = Pay first.
Rippling = Automate first.
Choosing the right HR software is not about the most features, it’s about getting the right features. Now let’s compare Rippling, Gusto, and BambooHR in five key areas for SMBs.
1. Onboarding Experience
BambooHR: Great onboarding experience with a customizable welcome email, the ability to e-sign documents, and checklists. It’s polished and employee-centric.
Gusto: Simple onboarding setup with to-dos for the employer and employee. Easy for a first-time user, but a little rigid.
Rippling: Fully automated workflow. New hires can receive offer letters, enroll in benefits, and provision apps/devices in one automated workflow.
Best Overall for Automation: Rippling
Best Overall for Ease: BambooHR
2. Payroll & Benefits
Gusto: Payroll is the primary focus - you will receive automatic tax reporting and benefits administration, and contractor payment as a basic tool.
BambooHR: They support payroll, only in the U., and it is an add-on for customers. Best for companies that do not want a complicated payroll, yet.
Rippling: You can run payroll in minutes for both your U.S. employees and your workforce globally. You can sync information in real time if an employee updates it to minimize mistakes.
Best option for U.S. payroll: Gusto
Best option for scaling internationally: Rippling
Gusto’s pricing is clear and cost-effective for U.S. payroll. Rippling offers global payroll. BambooHR requires an add-on.
3. User Experience & Interface
BambooHR: It is simple and modern; anyone can find what they are looking for quickly, even if they are not an HR person.
Gusto: Generally very intuitive to payroll administrators and employees, even if some feel the user interface is outdated.
Rippling: A very sleek and powerful platform, yet the strength can overwhelm smaller functional teams.
Best UI for smaller teams: BambooHR
Best UI for true power users: Rippling
4. Connectors and IT Administration
Rippling: Over 500 connectors; unique offering for device management and app provisioning
Gusto and BambooHR: Core connectors (QuickBooks, Slack, etc.) but no IT capability.
Best for connected teams: Rippling
5. Compliance and Reporting
All provide basic compliance reminders.
Rippling provides automated labor law compliance and allows custom workflows.
Gusto assists with tax compliance and benefits legislation.
Let's face it - cost matters. Especially for SMBs, when they buy an HR product, they want to see value quickly. So, where do Rippling, Gusto, and BambooHR come in?
Base Price: Starting at $40/month + $6/user (monthly) for Simple Plan
Mid-tier: Plus Plan (includes PTO management, advanced reports, next-day payroll, and others) is $80/month + $12/user.
Best For: U.S.-Based small business of some kind, that primarily just wants payroll, and wants to have a fixed-cost, predictable pricing model.
Pros: Predictable and transparent pricing - no surprises. Best for small teams (<50).
Cons: Features can be locked to a tier, and may need to upgrade just to have an effective basic (like time tracking).
Pricing: Not available to the public- you will need to ask for a quote
Usually between $6 - $8/user/month
Payroll and benefits tracking are add-ons
Best for: Organizations that prioritize people management over payroll, or with a current payroll provider
Pros: Flexible and clean interface; excellent value for core HR
Cons: Pricing is not public, making budgeting challenging; native payroll tools are limited
Base Minimum Price: $35/month, $8/user/month
Price increases relative to modules added (IT, Finance, etc.)
Best for: Growing SMB's who want everything in one stack, including both IT and device management
Pros: Modular pricing means you only pay for what you use
Cons: Can get expensive quickly when bundling multiple modules
Bottom Line:
For small U.S.-focused teams, Gusto is the most transparent and affordable
Bamboo HR will serve you well if your HR needs outweigh payroll
Rippling is powerful and scalable, but be prepared to pay a premium
McKinsey’s findings show that SMBs make up the backbone of the economy but struggle with productivity, highlighting the strategic value of choosing the right HR systems to scale.
In some cases, the most effective way to choose a tool is to see it in action. Below, we highlight how each of the HR platforms we discussed helped actual SMBs, from different industries, needs, and stages of growth.
Gusto: The Payroll Killer for a Bakery Chain in Growth Mode
A bakery chain with 25 employees and looking to expand to three locations made the decision to start using Gusto to ease payroll and automate onboarding new employees. Because they had hundreds of hourly employees, payroll is fast and features many payroll cycles during the payroll week; speed and compliance mattered! Gusto’s features include auto-calculation for payroll, tax filing, and direct deposit, making payday feel painless. They were doing it without an HR team! And the employees appreciated self-service capabilities in accessing payslips and W-2s.
Why it worked: Payroll was the pain point. Gusto stepped in with a solution that was both cost-smart and seamless. The issue found its fix through Gusto’s practical and budget-friendly approach.
BambooHR: People and HR Take Center Stage at a Design Agency
A creative agency with 40 employees used BambooHR to allow their firm to manage hiring, employee records, and performance reviews in one platform. They didn't need payroll capabilities, but wanted better insight into employee engagement and retention. BambooHR's clean user interface, customizable workflows, and goal-setting and tracking tools gave their small HR team capabilities it didn't know it had.
Why it worked: Culture and performance mattered more than payroll.
A remote-first tech start-up with 60 staff scaled quickly with Rippling. They needed device management, payroll, onboarding, and benefits in multiple countries. Rippling allowed them to provision laptops, assign training, and pay staff all around the world, in one place, from one vendor.
Why it worked: It was an integrated stack, designed to meet the demands of growth and complexity, and capable of being scaled.
Takeaway:
Go with Gusto if payroll is your bottleneck.
Go with BambooHR if you do not want to focus on people management.
Go with Rippling if you are scaling in systems or countries.
We all know that no platform lives in a vacuum anymore when it comes to technology. Your HR product can't be siloed away from the technology stack you already have in your finance, collaboration, or productivity products. Let's see how these three stack up.
Gusto features integrations with industry-standard accounting solutions like QuickBooks, Xero, and FreshBooks, as well as native connections to Slack, Expensify, and TSheets. However, its ecosystem only touches on the financial functions at the core of it, or the timekeeping aspect - it is neither deep on IT integrations, nor performance, nor recruitment integrations.
Strength: Simple for accounting and payroll workflows.
Weakness: Missing depth in IT or recruitment ecosystems.
Best For: SMBs that have simple accounting + payroll systems.
BambooHR offers over 50 integrations with other tools in ATS (e.g., Greenhouse, Workable), performance management, e-signature tools (DocuSign, HelloSign), and learning systems. Payroll work is limited in integration unless you use your payroll add-on app; however, for teams primarily focused on HR, it offers a lot in terms of flexibility, thanks to an open API.
Strength: Ecosystem of HR tools and configurable workflows.
Weakness: Payroll can feel like a disconnected aspect of their platform without using add-ons, so you buy into it.
Best for: teams needing the flexibility of different hiring and performance tools.
Rippling is more than an HR system; it’s a full-on Employee Operating System. You can use it to integrate with anything from Google Workspace, Slack, GitHub, Salesforce, Office 365, Zoom, and deep into your device management platforms. And you can automate onboarding flows that provision email accounts, assign training, set user permissions, etc. Instantly
Strength: deep, automated workflows deep into departments.
Weakness: it may be overkill in some cases for simple tea,s- or expensive as you add new modules to your account.
Best for: Tech-forward SMBs scaling their hiring across roles, regions, and tools.
Ecosystem Summary:
Gusto: Focused on what it is, but limited.
BambooHR: Modular and HR-deep.
Rippling: Cross-functional and enterprise-capable.
Gusto is attractive for small firms wanting to have payroll and benefits consolidated. Gusto offers a clean, user-friendly experience but doesn't scale well for companies needing deeper hiring or employee performance features.
BambooHR is best for people-focused teams looking for hiring, culture and pe, and performance management streamlining. The user interface is digestible, yet payroll incurs an additional cost, and some integrations have an additional setup.
Rippling is good for rocketship startups looking to integrate HR, IT, and finance in an automated way, while they have the flexibility to scale. The, re is a pronounced learning curve and will incur further costs as you add more and more modules.
While they have some capabilities in common, each product has its strengths - the right choice depends befo, re anything else on you, regarding ur team size, your team's priorities and y, and our growth rate.
Which is the best HR platform depends on the size and complexity of your team, as well as where you plan to go.
If you are a lean startup or small business, Gusto should be your platform of choice. It makes payroll and benefits feel just like they should: automated. It's automation just works—without breaking the bank or taking up your precious time.
If you are managing a midsize team that is growing or focused on culture and retention, BambooHR provides a good mix of simplicity through usable interfaces, performance management, and onboarding/hiring assistance. They market themselves as a people-first platform, and after evaluating them, we found they nailed the "scaling thoughtfully" component.
If you are managing hybrid teams, rapid onboarding, and/or payroll for international employees, Rippling will bring the brawn. Its automation engine and unified IT/HR allow you to scale complexity while also maintaining control.
Beyond those three platforms, you may have additional considerations. Here are some additional answers to a variety of questions you may have.
"Unlock Smarter SaaS Decisions – Get the Latest Reviews & Insights Delivered Weekly!"
Join 10,000+ SaaS leaders who trust us for unbiased, expert recommendations.
Recommended Blogs:
What is the best HR Software tool to use for my startup?
Will I be able to transfer to another platform later?
Are they safe and secure to store my employee information?
What solution is the most configurable?
When I reach out for help, will someone truly be there?
